Mass Torts

Frenville Overruled Claims Arise Upon Exposure in the Third Circuit

By: Corinne E. Donohue
St. John's Law Student
American Bankruptcy Institute Law Review Staff

In Jeld-Wen, Inc. v. Van Brunt (In re Grossman’s Inc.),[1] the Third Circuit applied a new test for determining when a “claim” arises under the Bankruptcy Code.[2] Specifically, the Third Circuit held that a “claim” arises when an individual is exposed to a product or conduct that causes injury, and not when the injury is manifested.[3] Grossman’s involved asbestos-related tort claims.[4] The Third Circuit held that even though claimants’ injury did not manifest itself until after bankruptcy, the claim arose pre-petition when claimant was exposed to asbestos.[5] In Grossman’s the Third Circuit reconsidered and overruled its previous “accrual” test in Avellino & Bienes v. M. Frenville Co. (In re M. Frenville Co.).[6]